X

Every Nintendo Franchise, Ranked

by Jason Dietz — 
"Mario Kart 8 Deluxe" (Nintendo)

With the wildly successful launch of the Switch 2 earlier this year, Nintendo has once again reinforced its status as perhaps the preeminent gaming hardware company of all time. But what has enabled that multi-decade hardware success has been software: More than any other console manufacturer, Nintendo has long depended on exclusive, first-party titles to drive its hardware success, many showcasing the creativity, playfulness, and humor that Nintendo is known for. The result is that Nintendo has some of the most lucrative game franchises of all time, led by its iconic Mario and Legend of Zelda properties.

Which of those franchises have consistently impressed game critics, and which have failed to delight? Below, we rank every Nintendo-published game franchise from worst to best by the average Metascore for each franchise.

Some notes on our methodology:

  • Only franchises with at least 4 scored games were eligible.
  • For the biggest franchises, like Mario, we divided them into smaller lists of subseries (for Mario, that means separate listings for Super Mario, Paper Mario, Mario Party, etc.).
  • Though remakes and ports are included below, we excluded DLC, most multi-game compilations, games on non-Nintendo hardware (i.e., iOS games), arcade and Game & Watch games (which we don't have scores for), and Japan-only releases.
  • For some older pre-Metacritic titles for which we do not have Metascores, we substituted scores from our now-defunct sister site GameRankings, which used a similar 0-100 scoring system. (Those scores are marked with an asterisk below.)
  • Release years listed below reflect North American release dates. (Older titles were often released earlier in Japan.)

44. Pokémon Rumble

pokemonrumble

43. Pokémon Mystery Dungeon

43. Pokémon Mystery Dungeon

42. Chibi-Robo!

42. Chibi-Robo!

41. Donkey Kong spinoffs

41. Donkey Kong spinoffs

(tie) 39. Pokémon Stadium

(tie) 39. Pokémon Stadium

(tie) 39. Dr. Mario

(tie) 39. Dr. Mario

38. Mario Party

38. Mario Party

37. Brain Age

37. Brain Age

36. Nintendo Labo

36. Nintendo Labo

35. Kirby spinoffs

35. Kirby spinoffs

34. Pokémon puzzle games

34. Pokémon puzzle games

33. Luigi

33. Luigi

32. Wii Sports

32. Wii Sports

31. Mario Tennis

31. Mario Tennis

30. Excite

30. Excite

29. Art Style

29. Art Style

28. Hyrule Warriors

28. Hyrule Warriors

27. Art Academy

27. Art Academy

26. WarioWare

26. WarioWare

25. Yoshi

25. Yoshi

24. Mario vs. Donkey Kong

24. Mario vs. Donkey Kong

23. Animal Crossing

23. Animal Crossing

22. Style Savvy

22. Style Savvy

21. Kirby (main series)

21. Kirby (main series)

20. Star Fox

20. Star Fox

19. Wario (platformers)

19. Wario (platformers)

18. Picross

18. Picross

17. Mario Golf

17. Mario Golf

16. BoxBoy!

16. BoxBoy!

15. Donkey Kong (main series)

15. Donkey Kong (main series)

14. Fire Emblem

14. Fire Emblem

13. Pikmin

13. Pikmin

(tie) 11. Pokémon (core series)

(tie) 11. Pokémon (core series)

(tie) 11. Paper Mario

(tie) 11. Paper Mario

10. Mario & Luigi

10. Mario & Luigi

9. Metroid

9. Metroid

8. F-Zero

8. F-Zero

7. Nintendo Wars

7. Nintendo Wars

6. Pushmo

6. Pushmo

5. Mario Kart

5. Mario Kart

4. Xenoblade Chronicles

4. Xenoblade Chronicles

3. Super Mario

3. Super Mario

2. Super Smash Bros.

2. Super Smash Bros.

1. The Legend of Zelda

1. The Legend of Zelda