Judge Denise Cote
FORTUNE --Apple (AAPL) pulled no punches in the 65-page brief it filed Tuesday, asking a higher court to overturn the controversial results of last year's e-book antitrust trial and placing blame for the outcome squarely on the shoulders of the judge who heard the case.
In Apple's view, U.S. District Judge Denise Cote was not only wrong about the law when she ruled that the company orchestrated a conspiracy with publishers to fix the price of e-books, she was wrong about the facts as well.
The key issue of law is the same one that was raised at trial: That the antitrust rules that restrain the actions of direct competitors are not the same as those governing the actions of a vertical player -- as Apple was in its dealings with the publishers.
The key issue of fact has to do with the judge's timeline of the case.
"Apple's entry into the conspiracy had to start somewhere," Judge Cote wrote in her July 2013 decision, "and the evidence is that it started at those initial [Dec. 2009] meetings in New York City with the Publishers" when the company "made a conscious commitment" to join a pre-existing conspiracy to violate the Sherman Antitrust Act.
"This finding forms the bedrock of the court's entire decision and is demonstrably wrong," Apple told the U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit. "The undisputed record reflects that Apple had no prior dealings in the publishing industry and that everything it knew it had gleaned from public sources—like reports in The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal—none of which reported on a conspiracy."
Apple knew before those initial meetings that the publishers were frustrated with Amazon (AMZN), which at the time controlled nearly 90% of the e-book market. They hated that Amazon was selling their most popular titles for $9.99 -- below cost -- and were afraid of getting squeezed out of what little profit they still had. The judge herself recognized that Amazon's dominant position "strengthened [Apple's] hand in proposing [a] new business model to the Publishers."
"Apple seized the moment and brilliantly played its hand," she wrote.
Steve Jobs later called this an "aikido move," referring to a Japanese martial arts maneuver that uses the power of a stronger opponent against itself.
"Such a move is not unlawful—it is the essence of competition," Apple asserted Tuesday. "There is no evidence, and the district court did not find, that Apple had knowledge of the phone calls, meetings, and dinners among the publishers featured so prominently in the court's ruling."
"The district court's judgment and injunction should be reversed, and judgment should be entered for Apple," the brief concludes. "In the alternative, a new trial before a different district judge should be granted."
A spokesperson for the government said it would file its response in May.
After four days of sniping from security experts, Apple pushes through a fix.
FORTUNE -- For all the fuss stirred up by the press and the cybersecurity community, we'll probably never know what kinds of secrets -- if any -- flowed through the security hole in the operating systems of millions of Macs between Friday, when the fact of its existence was inadvertently revealed, and Tuesday afternoon, when it was nailed MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 25, 2014 3:54 PM ET
Cook's hometown paper has unearthed a trove of unflattering yearbook pictures.
FORTUNE -- According to the Mobile Press-Register, Tim Cook played trombone, sold ads for the yearbook, and was the second-best student in his Robertsdale High School graduating class. The valedictorian, Teresa Prochaska Huntsman, works as an application developer analyst in Boise, Idaho.
More photos and bioperse: Tim Cook -- Apple CEO and Robertsdale's favorite son
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 25, 2014 11:17 AM ET
Could Apple do business in a state that sanctions discrimination against gays?
FORTUNE -- Apple (AAPL) has confirmed that it urged Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer over the weekend to veto a bill that would allow business owners with strongly held religious beliefs to deny service to gays and lesbians.
Since the Arizona statehouse passed the measure last Thursday, Gov. Brewer has faced growing pressure to kill the bill that opponents characterize as "state-sanctioned discrimination."
Three state senators MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 25, 2014 8:37 AM ET
Monday, Feb. 24, would have been his 59th birthday
FORTUNE -- As we did when he was still running Apple (AAPL), we'd like to celebrate Steve Jobs' life by re-posting what may be the most personal public speech this intensely private man ever made: His commencement address to the Stanford University class of 2005.
If you haven't seen it — or haven't heard it recently — we give you Steve Jobs on life, MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 24, 2014 10:15 AM ET
Also Safari, Twitter, Calendar, iBooks, FaceTime, Keynote and Software Update.
FORTUNE -- Ashkan Soltani, an independent computer security expert best known for analyzing Edward Snowden's NSA leaks for the Washington Post, has published a list of applications running Mac OS X 10.9 that he says are vulnerable to the same security hole Apple (AAPL) patched in its mobile operating system on Friday.
They include apps used by millions of Mac users every day: MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 24, 2014 9:56 AM ET
Did U.S. government spies create the security hole that Apple patched last week?
FORTUNE -- You don't have to put on a tin hat to find the timing of the "Apple" entry in the attached Powerpoint slide suspicious, although a tin hat probably helps.
The slide, marked TOP SECRET, was one of the first documents leaked to The Guardian and the Washington Post by NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden last June. It lays out MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 23, 2014 9:14 AM ET
But Samsung had largest share in 2013 of fastest-growing segment: less than $30K a year.
FORTUNE -- The good news for Apple (AAPL) in a report issued Thursday by the NPD Group is that it still owns the biggest share of the richest and most profitable segment of the U.S. smartphone market.
One third of Apple's U.S. sales in 2013 were to Americans making more than $100,000 a year, and of that MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 21, 2014 12:08 PM ETAlso on the 'top secret' list: Johnny Carson, Latino Baseball, Social Awareness, Peanuts.
FORTUNE -- There used to be a rule that you had to be dead for at least 10 years before your face could appear on a U.S. postage stamp. That got lifted in 2011, in time for the Postal Service's Citizen Stamp Advisory Committee to approved a 2015 series collectible commemorating Apple's (AAPL) Steve Jobs (1955-2011).
According to the Washington MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 21, 2014 8:34 AM ET
Think of it, writes Kara Swisher, as the price Facebook must pay for not having a mobile OS.
FORTUNE -- Judging from the sheer volume of commentary generated by Facebook's (FB) $19 billion offer for WhatsApp, it seems everybody in the tech world is having a hard time swallowing the sticker price, even if most of it comes in the form of Facebook shares that may or may not be overvalued.
$19 billion puts MORE
Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 20, 2014 10:51 AM ET
